The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly

There is no battle that is waged over a wider range of fields than that between the hero and the villain. From horror to humor, romance to thrillers, they come in many guises but they are always there.

We have real heroes, anti-heroes, tragic heroes and heroes as a result of circumstance. Villains with purpose, villains with a history connecting to the hero, world domination seeking super-villains and those villains that are also a rather tragic victims of their circumstances.  Obviously, there are a great many more types of both that I could list, but I fear this post would never be finished. Plus, listing the options that are available to you when choosing both characters for your novel is not what this post is about. (although, note to self… it could be a good post for next week.)

No, the question I want to raise is about writing these two characters. The question itself is simple. Who do you prefer to write?

I can certainly see the charm in writing the Hero, I mean he is the champion. The fan favorite. Your hero is the character that is responsible for the happy ending, or at least for putting up the good fight. He stands up for what is right, he defends the weak and will risk his own lives for the other characters. Maybe not in a literal sense, but certain in a figurative sense of the phrase. Ok, heroes can be flawed, they can have a hidden darkside, but still, when compared to the villain, they are the without doubt, the good guy.

But come on, writing the villain is just great fun.

Personally, I think writing a villain is a more liberating thing for a writer, because with villains, the gloves can come off.

Take even the most flawed hero in literary history, and you will see that the writer didn’t go too far. You can’t. (You could argue that the anti-hero is a hero pushed too far, but even then there are limits, because there has to be something stopping the anti-hero becoming a villain.) Whereas the villain, he doesn’t have to be bound by a moral code. He can do what he wants when he wants.  He’s the bad guy after all. The reader is supposed to hate him. To want to see him fail.

Ok, I admit, there is a level, and boundary for both character, but for the villain that boundary is the plot of the novel itself. His actions cannot be too extreme for the type of novel he is in. Other than that, world domination is his oyster.

 What do you think? Is is more fun to write a hero or a villain?

7 thoughts on “The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly

  1. OK, Alex. My villains are not necessarily human, and are more likely a natural process taken to extremes. I have had (a) villain(s) who were faceless hordes of evil dedicated subtley mutated humans, but I may not do that again. (See “The Real World of Mamapacha,” coming very soon.) But, my villains are more likely to be, for example, an asteroid sent on a horrible mission by an out-of control-carbon entity on a diamond planet. (See “Site 39, Blue Orb). I try to creat villains that drive me to science textbooks so I can use real science and concoct “feasible extrapolations” therefrom. The people in my books are sometimes deliberately “Tom Sawyerish” and sometimes merely observers, but sometimes do not survive intact. I do seem to destroy large populations at once, though, for example, everyone on earth except for four folks + a computer. (See “Ethan – Site 39”) The research work, for plausibility is enjoyable.

    1. I see where you are coming from. I did forget about the villains that are not a person but rather an even or an act. I will admit your writing sounds really interestng. I am going to have to check it all out.

      Thanks for commenting.

  2. Villains! Hands down 😀 There’s usually something sexy about them. The only ones I hate are the Uriah Heep type villains – you know, the kind who have something greasy about them and whine a lot. They’re just creepy.

    1. I know what you mean. There is a certain villain that just makes you feel dirty to write about.

      There is most definately something about a villain that makes them cooler – I hate to use that word, but it is 05.30 and I’ve not had a coffee yet so it will do for now – than the heros. I mean, I also find that adding a touch of goodness to a villain is more fun than adding a splash of darkness to a hero.

  3. Villains: always more fun. Granted there those villains so despicable it’s a wonder how they could be “fun” in any sense, but I think a writer’s fun is different from what the villain considers fun. Make any sense?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s